Grab My HeartThe people who make a life

Long Friendships

The friend with children and the friend without

One of the most common ways an adult friendship fails is a divergence neither person chose. What actually causes the drift, beyond the obvious lack of time.

African American man in white shirt talking on a cellphone in an indoor setting.
Photograph by Tima Miroshnichenko via Pexels
Editorial note. Independent reporting and analysis. Nothing here is sponsored or paid for. How we work.

Most explanations of friendship across different life stages stop at the point where it starts to matter. This one carries on.

The short version

  • The obstacle is scheduling and available hours before it is anything else.
  • Both parties commonly misread the other's silence as a judgement.
  • Friendships survive by changing the format rather than by matching life stages.

The obvious part and the less obvious part

A new parent loses most discretionary evenings, which is the explanation everybody reaches for and is genuinely most of the problem. The less obvious part is that the two people's days stop overlapping, so even a free hour is at seven in the morning rather than nine at night. Conversation also diverges, since one person's daily material is now largely about a subject the other has no stake in.

The childless friend often stops asking, on the reasonable ground that they do not want to be tedious about it, which reads as disinterest. Each of these is small, and together they can end a fifteen-year friendship inside two years.

The misreadings on both sides

The parent frequently assumes their friend finds them boring now, and adjusts by talking less about their actual life. The childless friend often assumes they are no longer wanted, since invitations stop and their own invitations get declined.

Neither assumption is usually true, and both are entirely rational given the available evidence. There is also a real asymmetry in who can initiate, since the parent's calendar has less slack and more unpredictability. Saying the assumption out loud, once, resolves a surprising proportion of these cases.

What genuinely changes

Spontaneity is the first casualty, and a friendship that ran on last-minute plans has lost its entire operating method. The parent becomes considerably less interesting company for a period, because sleep deprivation is real and its effects on conversation are substantial.

In the long run, the childless friend's life may also change in ways that get less acknowledgement, including a career move, a relationship or a bereavement. There is often an unspoken sense that one person's constraints are legitimate and the other's are optional, which causes real damage. Both people's time is finite, and treating one person's demands as automatically superior is what turns a scheduling problem into a grievance.

Formats that work across the divide

Meeting in the daytime at weekends, in a park or a kitchen rather than a restaurant, removes most of the practical obstacles at once. Turning up at their house and accepting the interruptions is worth more than an evening out that has to be arranged a month ahead.

The unglamorous truth is that being useful, holding something, driving somewhere, is a genuine route back into a parent's life and is remembered for years. Short frequent contact suits this period better than long infrequent contact, since a parent has many small gaps and almost no large ones.

The parent should hold a slot occasionally too, because permanent one-way accommodation eventually exhausts the other person.

The reverse asymmetry

Parents sometimes assume a childless friend has unlimited time, which is both inaccurate and quietly insulting. Friends without children may be dealing with caring responsibilities, health, work or an unwanted childlessness that nobody has asked about.

Between old friends, involuntary childlessness in particular makes this friendship painful in ways that are rarely raised, and the friend may withdraw for reasons unrelated to the friendship. Asking about their life with the same energy they are expected to bring to yours is the whole of the fix. A friendship where only one person's circumstances are treated as real will not survive whichever direction it runs in.

Families differ so widely that any general rule survives only until it meets yours.

What it looks like later

Many of these friendships resume when the children get older and the discretionary hours return, sometimes after a gap of years. The ones that resume are usually the ones where minimal contact was maintained rather than abandoned entirely. It helps to think of the intensive years as a period of reduced service rather than as an ending, and to say so explicitly.

In the long run, some friendships do not resume, and it is worth being honest that a divergence in life stage genuinely ends some of them. Keeping the channel warm costs a handful of messages a year, which is a very cheap option on a friendship you would like back.

The takeaway

Change the time of day and the venue before you conclude that the friendship has run out of things in common.

Nobody keeps everyone. Choose the few and be serious about them.

Questions readers ask

Should I keep inviting a friend who always says no?

Yes. Invitations signal that they are still wanted, which is the thing that quietly stops. Ask them to keep declining rather than dropping off the list.

How do I stay interested in a friend who only talks about their children?

Ask about the parts other people do not ask about, and ask about them as a person. Most parents are relieved to be given somewhere else to go.

Long Friendshipschildrenlife stagesdivergence
More in Long Friendships
Vivaan Talwar
Contributing writer, Grab My Heart

Vivaan writes about long-distance friendship and the phone calls that keep it alive.

Also by Vivaan Talwar